kiss the ground fact checking

Although, when I watched it for the third time, it became obvious that the biology 101 lessons from Ray were cleverly used to dance around the fact there is no solid science to back up Savory and Browns claims. 209 South Oak Ridge Drive It also doesnt spend most of its time talking about whos to blame, and its actually mostly about looking for solutions for our futures, and did include suggestions about what we, as ordinary people, can do. With no plants to transpire and create the water vapour which condenses to rain, local rainfall also fails, turning the area to desert. There is a large focus on America, but the issues here in the UK (and the rest of the world) are similar, so it is applicable to all. I honestly thought it would stand on its own. Ray: Hope. how to make a chi ball visible for beginners Keagy's Best Price Plumbing Ill start with the hardest and get easier. Science can provide us with some valid assumptions, but it does not provide recipes. Soil organic matter [SOM] is largely created through microbial necromass. Does the movie miss the mark in any way, or would you have liked to have seen particulartopics covered that were not? I am alive!. Ive been interested in and learning more about the importance of soil health for years. A major criticism is that there is a lack of science to back up claims. https://asu.pure.elsevier.com/en/publications/potential-mitigation-of-midwest-grass-finished-beef-production-em, Machmuller, M. B., Kramer, M. G., Cyle, T. K., Hill, N., Hancock, D., & Thompson, A. As someone who has spent the past 25-plus years working to educate anyone who will listen as to the benefits of regenerative ag, I can say with certainty that the snowball is finally rolling downhill! The problem is, the lay viewer who is not across the science, and blinded by the message of hope, is likely to confuse the role of cows in holistic grazing with instruction that we should continue eating meat at current rates (as long as its grass-fed) and perhaps even double down on our meat consumption. There is not enough money in the world to get me to move from Gods country, North Dakota! doi:10.1093/jas/skx060 http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/jas/skx060, Stanley, P. L., Rowntree, J. E., Beede, D. K., DeLonge, M. S., & Hamm, M. W. (2018). Healthy soils can store more carbon than all the trees and plants combined, so is more important than saving the rainforests or the ocean phytoplankton in reversing climate change! Makes sense why the documentary didnt go there! FACT-CHECK. The sort of solution you might suspect is at the top of all climate scientists lists. berger 215 hybrid 300 win mag. Ray Archuleta, previously a conservation agronomist with the Natural Resources Conservation Service and the co-founder of the Soil Health Academy, stands at the front talking to the farmers, and to us. At Novel Hand, Im specifically interested in learning about topics related to justice and poverty, and how to create equitable, sustainable impact. Its not just about more trees, the carbon that can be stored in healthy, organic material rich soils is much greater. I help with that too , Join my supportive community to move to eco-friendly eating and receive tips, advice, recipes and support. Instagram @maggie.eileen.art). The first point that I think deserves our attention, before getting into the science on the reversal claim, is the way the producers wanted you to see holistic grazing. The message gets across, but the film downplays a meaningful call to action. The movie funders wanted to make this movie all about organic farming, but Gabe and I worked on him and showed him that organic farming can be as destructive as conventional farmingand to his credit, Josh learned what regenerative farming was all about. Farmers need to learn how to regenerate and take care of the soil. Plowing the earth, preparing fields for planting, exposing bare soil. Its a system of thinking and working that takes knowledge, skill, experience, endurance, affinity, if you've got it, and a lot of hard work, just like any other difficult undertaking. As a side note, the documentary routinely employed uses numerous fear-mongering tactics to scare the viewer into grasping for whatever solution comes next. Or this breakdown of the many myths he perpetuates inThe International Journal ofBiodiversity. Stardom is a complicated thing, but at least all that money and power are being put to good use. You can make change and make a difference, even if you have struggled in the past to make change and feel like a failure. The natural carbon cycle involves carbon release by animals consuming plant and other organic materials and releasing the carbon as carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. But I also experienced the same misleadingparadigms from the conservative groups like Farm Bureau and other commodities groups. Unfortunately, overtly telling people they need to cut down on their meat consumption for this change in agriculture to work isnt going to help with the documentarys popularity. Its predicted that, if we can scale up some of these farming methods over the next 30 years, we can REVERSE global warming. Yes, whats on our plate is even more important than where its come from or buying local. Hosted by Robbie Lockie, Plant Based News delivers pioneering vegan news and ethical views weekly. Your email address will not be published. Put simply, there are no healthy humans without a healthy planet. Hi there to all, for the reason that I am genuinely keen of reading this websites post to be updated on a regular basis. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. It's a nonprofit organization that he leads today as executive director. The bonus being that plant-rich dietary patterns just so happen to also be whatmajor health institutionsand progressive Government departments likeHealth Canadaare advocating for to tackle rising rates of obesity and chronic disease, and improve quality of life. I doubt this will require an agent or a move haha! As Hannah Ritchie, Phd (Geosciences) puts it: Whether you buy it from the farmer next door or from far away, it is not the location that makes the carbon footprint of your dinner large, but the fact that it is beef.. Factory farms are good at one thing producing a lot of meat in a short period of time to feed a growing appetite for meat. Im not suggesting we should only be changing our diet but given it has greater potential to reduce greenhouse gas emissions you would think it would have been given more emphasis than putting cows on pasture. Although I would have liked more with real life farmers and ranchers, it is hard to put together a documentary that will appeal across the spectrum from rural to urban communities, young and old, and everyday people to activists. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Regenerative agriculture combines 4 practices. If the U.S shifted away from intensive livestock farming to traditional grazing, its been calculated that theavailable grasslands would only be able to produce 27 percent of the countries current beef supply. This is a review Im very familiar with having read through it front to back a handful of times. Kiss the Ground has the perfect documentary mix of celebrity activists and wise elder scientists. Tilling, the process of pulling up the soil to plant seeds, is destructive to the soil. shabu shabu groupon. best charter schools in nashville. Many of the pesticides and fertilisers have been derived from poison gases used in warfare (chemical warfare and poison used in gas chambers). Kiss the Ground. Practically speaking this looks like the plate below perhaps this could be The Regenerative Plate that Kiss the Ground adopts in their communication going forwards. The elephant in the room during the documentary is that they completely failed to mention that a significant amount of the land dedicated to animal agriculture across the world (not all but certainly a lot) needs to be restored to forests (the number one driver of deforestation is animal agriculture) to get anywhere close to meeting our climate goals. Thank you for the review. The evidence for this claim is research-based, clearly communicated, and visually supported with animations that illustrate submicroscopic events like carbon cycling and expansive drone shots for grand reveals, like the actual desert plateau that is turned back into rolling green farmland. Monocropping further exacerbates the issue, as the same crop is grown year on year, for miles in the case of US farms, microbial diversity cannot increase. Thank you for this article! Tilling, the process of pulling up the soil to plant seeds, is destructive to the soil. He's a lover of people and of life. Weaker soils need more chemicals. Unfortunately, there are still very few about, especially in the UK. Try: Compost Toilets in Africa: Human Feces as Fertilizer | Thrive4Good (thriveforgood.org) or GiveLove. Filmmakers Josh Tickell and Rebecca Tickell wound up spending seven years making their latest doc, "Kiss the Ground," and all along the way they worried that by the end of the process there . Looking for a way to kill the quarantine boredom? So cows can actually be used to reverse desertification. Ray: Initially, when I first met the Kiss the Ground group, I told them that I was really concerned about how they should approach the landowners. We started ploughing/tilling because it was easier for us to upscale. Kiss the Groundgave the microphone to Ranchers Alan Savory and Gabe Brown, but we didnt hear about any legitimate science testing out whether the claims they were making truly hold up? Anecdote and expert opinion or theories are at the bottom of the evidence hierarchy, and its not until we see the findings from higher levels of science, reproduced on scale, that we can begin to have confidence in what we are observing. I just heard of the movie and wanted to find out a little more about it until I get time to watch it. The film uses creative graphics and visuals, along with striking NASA and NOAA footage, and illustrates how, by drawing down atmospheric carbon many of humankinds most pressing climate and environmental problems can be solved. Data from almost40,000 farms, and 119 countries, clearly shows us that a plant-based diet results in less greenhouse gas emissions, less pollution, less ocean acidification, and uses less water and land land which we can therefore free up and convert to forests to rapidly sequester carbon from our atmosphere. Use this compost for your beds rather than buying in compost or fertilisers. As long as its grass-fed. I am optimistic because the major issues we are currently facing economic stress, climate change, and food quality are all addressed by the same solution regenerating soil. What do you hope will be an outcome from the movie? They correctly state that Bison would pass through land and not be seen for around a year. If not, heres what you can do to join the regenerative farming movement, or at least help make things better . Regenerate America is an unprecedented coalition of farmers, businesses, nonprofits, and individuals from every corner of our country and all political stripes, convened by the national soil health 501 (c)3 nonprofit organization, Kiss the Ground. Kiss the Ground brings together a diverse coalition of scientists, farmers, and advocates to share this story, showcase the benefits of adopting regenerative agriculture, and build a movement aimed at renewing the planet's ecosystems. worlds leading climate scientists have to say about diet? Yes, theres no doubt ruminant poop can help improve soil quality, butthere are many types of regenerative agriculture that do not involve animalsoranimal manureand others that act as sanctuaries using animals on their land without sending them to slaughter. Links to some of the recent research supporting HM, Teague, W. R. (2018). (Source: Kiss the Ground). Over the years, tilling causes the soil to dirt, leaving it vulnerable to erosion and desertification. There seems to be an incredibly fine line between grazing just enough and overgrazing, which speaks to potentially whycrediblepeer-reviewed science has to date, failed to produce results that come close to what Alan Savory claims. It only takes a quick read of theDrawdown Reportto realize that this is absolutely unfounded its going to take an enormous amount of solutions to radically transform our energy and food systems to reverse climate change, and holistic grazing, while certainly better than intensive farming, is not the miracle carbon-sequestering practice that those watching are led to believe. Gabe: I would have liked the movie to highlight the importance of grazing animals. Nature strives for balance, and has a system for reversing the carbon released into the atmosphere using the growth of plants and their relationship with soil microbes. And as the documentary states, shifting us from climate warming to climate cooling. There was also no mention of tropical forest restoration which has significantly greater potential at pulling carbon out of the atmosphere compared to grazing cows on land no matter what practice is employed. I enjoyed Woody Harrelson as a narrator; he felt genuine. These will be using less chemicals and therefore come from healthier soils than normal veg; hugely better for soil biodiversity, natural biodiversity and your health. Bare soils are at great risk of erosion by heavy rain, and its also been shown that bare soils vary in temperature much more, so the microclimate is changed. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. (PLEASE VOTE November 3rd or earlier!! Essentially, Hawken and his team have created a long list of approximately 100 solutions, which when implemented together, would be capable of drawing down more carbon than we are emitting by 2050. Get our weekly editors newsletter & special offers delivered right to your inbox! The animals themselves arent the problem, where and how is the issue. Kris: No, but I am working on creating a virtual party with friends and family as we are scattered throughout the U.S. Ray: I will have a few people over. Its the misbalance of carbon that is the issue. Kiss the Ground features successful composting programs in San Francisco, Detroit, and Haiti. In fact, it was the single most important thing that lead Savory to question the science regarding overgrazing. Carrie Richards is not giving up. There are a few clues within the documentary that speak to this but they are by no means overtly clear to the viewer. Hopefully, this movie will help open many more. Im sure we can all agree that factory farming is a blight on humanity, and there is far too much mono-cropping, but assuming that its either this intensive form of animal agriculture or holistic grazing, is not accurate. Hotter soils during the day create hot rising air, which pushes any of these clouds away, and is how deserts are formed and grow. Plus FCRNs paper simply ignored the existing peer reviewed science with its claim that no such science exists. Kris:The time and effort that the team put into the interviews and edits as well as probably debating and refining the perspective the film takes should be commended. . The rest is projected to be lost within 60 years. Its not too long, but youll learn a lot from it. For a great deal of land, there are other, more evidence-based ways to sequester carbon. Ive listed these below in short, and then we will go through each together looking at the claims made and where the science lies: (These have also been covered in detail with Environmental Researcher Nicholas Carter (co-author of this article) in episode 104 and 111 on thePlant Proof podcast). After all, its communities of color, low-income communities, and immigrant communities who do the majority of the essential work of growing food and yet are most exploited and harmed by the agroindustrial complex. "All farmable soil could be gone in 60 years. "We should be thriving, the planet booming with life and abundance and the healthiest generation walking the earth. Early farming was small scale, so diversity was ensured, and combined the animals with plants, so the manures could be used as fertiliser, and crops grown on the land could feed the livestock. To move the conversation forward with the urgency this topic deserves, filmmakers have to use the emotion they elicit to generate willpower and give the public the conceptual framework they need to act, not just to feel. Doing just one will make a difference!! If youve heard anything about Tom Bradys lifestyle, you know that its extreme. All of us make critical decisions every day as we manage our lives and we dont consult the literature when making those decisions. It would be great to see what was meant to be there! Suggestions for viewers to compost and eat a plant-based diet come off as both insignificant and off the mark after the grand scheme of carbon cycling via production agriculture the whole film had been setting up. A Facebook video shows aerial footage of what appears to be large fissures or cracks in the Earth . We told him that you need to leave the audience with hope, which I believe he did. GHG Mitigation Potential of Different Grazing Strategies in the United States Southern Great Plains. I graduated from Vanderbilt University with degrees in Political Science, Economics and Spanish, and I currently study law in Texas. Using compelling graphics and visuals, along with striking NASA and NOAA footage, the film artfully illustrates how, by drawing down atmospheric carbon, soil is . kisstheground. A powerful message during a time where the climate emergency is without a doubt causing climate anxiety. Use your local food waste recycling system, and if they dont have one, write to your local council to ask for a food waste collection system. Which would net off the existing emissions we make, at least stabilising things. Half are experts working in their respective fields, and the rest are celebrity activists for whom regenerative agriculture and climate change is more or less a cause. But I wish people with platforms like documentary films or acting stardom would start framing issues with words that suggest physical work, like "repair" or fix or even "care for/take care of" (i.e. Parents need to know that Kiss the Ground is a 2020 documentary that addresses our current soil erosion crisis throughout the planet and the benefits of practicing "regenerative agriculture." Narrated by Woody Harrelson, the documentary features extensive interviews with farmers, scientists, activists, celebrities, and regular people as they help to create awareness of regenerative . I wanted the filmmakers to first understandto let the soil speak and to let nature teach us. Unfortunately, Savory seems to have led himself to believe that his unscientific approach should be expanded across the world really, tear down more forests to make room for holistic grazing? The film begins by examining . Sure, its easy to see with our own eyes that there is more life on land that is managed in a regenerative way, but in order to really know that it is a climate solution, we would need evidence that carbon levels in the soil are not only increasing but increasing by more than the emissions emitted by the animals involved in the system.

Signs Aries Man Is In Love With You, Articles K